Monday, September 7, 2009

Time to 'bite the bullet'

Our cabinet of curiosities at the front of the shop (I refer to it as my little museum of historical insignificia), contains several Civil War-era bullets. Both are lead. One appears to be a .69 caliber round shot; the other is a Minie Ball. They are moderately interesting in themselves, although not particularly uncommon in this part of the world.

What makes these two particularly interesting, at least to me, is that both carry teeth marks.

These bullets have a history. Someone, sometime, chewed on them. And that begs the question: why would anyone chew on a lead bullet? Or, in other words, why would anyone, literally, bite the bullet?

In common use, “to bite the bullet” means to bear down on a project, usually an onerous one, and just get it done. No matter how unpleasant the prospect is, you’ve got to just bite the bullet and do it.

The story goes that the phrase actually originated during the Civil War. On the battlefield, if a soldier was hit in an arm or a leg by a bullet, the bone would just shatter with shards and splinters of bone spreading in all directions. There was no way to repair the damage and the wound was actually life-threatening. The only remedy was amputation.

At the same time, anesthesia was rare. So when a soldier saw the surgeon approach in blood-splattered apron, he knew he was in for a hard couple of minutes. He would be laid on what passed for an operating table and his buddies would hold him down while the surgeon would wipe off his saw and begin.

Since there were no pain killers, the soldier would have a bullet placed between his teeth so he wouldn’t bite off his tongue or scream with the pain. Hence, teeth marks on the bullets.

It is a compelling story. It makes sense. It conforms to our notions of the Civil War and of the then-state of medicine. It conjures images of battlefields and of the times.

Turns out it is also wrong.

Civil War historian Janet Bucklew was our guest for "First Friday" this past weekend. She’s just written a book about Henry Janes, a country doctor from Vermont who served during the war. Janet, a Research Historian, is a veteran ranger at the Gettysburg National Military Park, and is also on staff at the National Museum of Civil War Medicine in Frederick, MD. You'd think she knows whereof she speaks.

Janet's presentation focused on Dr. Janes as a platform for discussing Civil War medicine in general. During the Q&A following her talk, she made a comment—almost as an afterthought—that belied the myth and burst my bubble. Soldiers never chewed bullets during the procedures, she said. The danger of swallowing was too great. Besides, there was anesthesia, so there was no real need.

The teeth marks probably came from pigs. According to Janet, the human jaw simply isn’t strong enough to cause the indentations in the bullets, while a pig’s jaw is. She said that swine would root around the battlefield following action, and would dine upon the corpses there and would at times wind up with a bullet in their mouth. That’s rather grizzly, but that makes sense.

Frankly, I like my story better. It certainly conjures a more romantic mental image.

I’ve tried to verify my version, but I can’t. The sources I’ve checked do repeat my version, but there are no attributions; in fact they all seem to be quoting one another, or talk about “common knowledge”. That’s simply not good enough when it comes to historical accuracy.

At the same time, I cannot verify Janet’s version either. But it does make more sense when you stop and think about it.

The problem with history is that you’re always studying someone else’s version of the facts. Even if you go back to primary sources, you’re dealing with someone’s impression or memory or view of what was said or what happened where. And you have to judge the source: how close were they to the event? Is their story self-serving or embellished? Are they telling the entire story or just what they want their audience to know?

So which version of the story do I tell when showing off our cabinet of curiosities? Maybe both, with an emphasis on history being what you make of it.

And that’s pretty much the point anyway, isn’t it?

33 comments:

  1. Well, Janet is right.

    Bullets were not needed since anesthesia was simply not rare. The Medical and Surgical History of the War of the Rebellion (published by no less off an authority than the US Surgeon General) states that 95% of all operations were done under general anethesetics and the remaining 5% of patientts either could not tolerate them due to already being barely alive with supressed vital signs (and likely not awake) or due to facial wounds that impaired the airway. In these last cases they could not have bitten anything.

    Surgeons reports, hospital records and journal abound that show anesthetics were used. If men were ever given anything to bite in an operation, it certainly would not have been anything so easily swallowed. Rope, leather or even sticks would have been better. But even reports of these items simply don;t seem to show up. The popular myth is hard to kill even when good documentation exists.

    Maybe the new forensic study of "bitten" bullets by the University of Michigan will shed some light on this subject.

    ReplyDelete
  2. what a story to be experienced.thanks...

    ReplyDelete
  3. Professional India based Responsive web design company India - Indian SEO Company 9999669114 is offering affordable SEO Services India for its clients And Online Reputation Management and mobile App Development.

    Best Internet Marketing Company in india
    Best Internet Marketing Company
    SEO Services India
    Best SEO Company India
    SEO Company in India
    Best SEO Company In india


    https://www.iaptris.com/
    info@iaptris.com
    support@iaptris.com
    9999669114


    ReplyDelete
  4. Luxury cars provide luxury car rental Dubai, exotic car rentals, Sports car rental, luxury cars in Dubai at very affordable rate for more details www.luxurycarsrentaldubai.co"

    Luxury Cars Rental Dubai
    Luxury Car Rental Dubai

    Visit here: http://www.luxurycarsrentaldubai.co/
    info@luxurycarsrentaldubai.co
    +971 56 845 2520

    ReplyDelete
  5. Rac Luxury Rental is Luxury Car Rental in Dubai.we Offers on sports car rental Dubai,rent luxury car Dubai, exotic car rental in Dubai. Rent lamborghini,farrari,audi,bentley,BMW,Mclaren,Mercedes,Porche,Range rover,Bugatti,Rolls Royce,etc call:- +971 56 845 2520

    Luxury Cars Rental Dubai
    Luxury Car Rental Dubai

    Visit Here: http://www.racluxuryrental.com/
    +971 56 845 2520

    ReplyDelete
  6. Enjoy our short video promoting Paithalmala Tourism. We are located inside the natural landscape of Paithalmala, which is the highest geographic peak in Kannur, located about 65 km from Kannur, becoming a favorite location for nature enthusiasts, creative photographers and international travelers


    Paithalmala Tourism

    Visit here: https://paithalmalatourism.org/

    Paithal Mala, Chandanakampara Road,, Near Paithal Mala, Vanchium., Kannur, Kerala 670582, India

    +91 9605482389 | 0460 2219062

    ReplyDelete
  7. Enjoy our short video promoting Paithalmala Tourism. We are located inside the natural landscape of Paithalmala, which is the highest geographic peak in Kannur, located about 65 km from Kannur, becoming a favorite location for nature enthusiasts, creative photographers and international travelers


    Paithalmala Tourism

    Visit here: https://paithalmalatourism.org/

    Paithal Mala, Chandanakampara Road,, Near Paithal Mala, Vanchium., Kannur, Kerala 670582, India

    +91 9605482389 | 0460 2219062

    ReplyDelete
  8. Property Management Software - Find online information about best property management software, real estate management software, online property management software, simple property management software and related more."


    Property Management Software

    http://www.myirent.com/
    9194736805

    iRent Sales
    719 Scott Street
    Wichita Falls, TX 76301
    919.473.6805

    ReplyDelete
  9. Cheapest Tickets with special offers for theme parks, attraction, tour, zoo, animal kingdom and universal studio in San Francisco, Atlanta, Boston, New york, Orlando, San Diego, Niagara, Chicago and more - All Park Tickets in USA

    All Park Tickets

    Visit here: http://www.allparktickets.com/

    ReplyDelete
  10. 7M Tours appreciates the support of all of our travelers, agents and suppliers. Please contact us if you have any questions or comments for us. Thank you for your continued business!

    USA Tour Operator
    Canada tour packages
    South America tour operator
    USA student groups educational tours
    USA student group tours packages
    USA budget fixed tours packages
    brazil tour operator

    Visit here: http://7mtours.com/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Inflatable boat Launching Wheels

    Launching wheels
    Inflatable pontoon
    Boat wheels

    Contact Us -17788196619


    Visit here for more info- http://www.bcimport.com/

    ReplyDelete
  12. Want to know the facts

    Hypnotherapy
    Clinical hypnotherapy
    Hypnotherapy cost
    Hypnotherapy training
    Hypnotherapy for weight loss



    Contact Us- 1-844-415-7124

    Visit here for more info- www.hypnotherapysole.com

    ReplyDelete
  13. he good thing about downtown is Best condos in mississauga

    Best condos in mississauga

    Best new mississauga condos



    Visit here for more info- https://newmississaugacondos.com/

    ReplyDelete
  14. MLS listings to proactively source private listings of Bay Area luxury properties.

    Luxury mls realtor
    Mls listings on golf course

    Visit here for more info- https://residential.golfshirehomes.com/

    ReplyDelete


  15. Real Estate listings located on a golf course.

    Luxury mls realtor
    Mls listings on golf course

    Visit here for more info- https://luxury.golfshirehomes.com/

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hypnosis is a state of inner absorption Click Down

    Hypnotherapy
    Hypnotherapy ontario
    Clinical hypnotherapy
    Hypnotherapy cost
    Hypnotherapy training


    1-844-415-7124


    For more update call us-1-844-415-7124

    Visit our website-http://www.hypnotherapysole.com/

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hrer best And & large selection of inflatable boats & rafts, with electric air pumps or Click Down

    Inflatable pontoon
    Launching wheels
    Small inflatable boat
    Inflatable boats canada
    Inflatable boat with motor




    For more update call us-1 7788196619

    Visit our website-http://www.hypnotherapysole.com/

    ReplyDelete
  18. Kingsway Counselling, Kent, Canada. Many likeser Click Down

    Best psychologist toronto
    Best psychiatrist Etobicoke
    Couples counselling Etobicoke
    GPT therapists


    Visit our website-http://www.counselling2wellness.com

    ReplyDelete
  19. greentours.com Tours is the leader in California Cannabis Tours Click Down

    Green tour
    420 tour
    420tour
    Cannabis tour
    Cannabis tours - Cooking 420
    Hollywood cannabis


    For more update call us-8558687420

    Visit our website-http://greentours.com/

    ReplyDelete
  20. your summer heat will soon start becoming out from now a days, what is enough opportunity for you to pick up the phone and call our Jaipur Escorts companies , the girls are still waiting for calls.READ MORE :-jaipur call girls


    ReplyDelete
  21. Orlandoprinters is one of the leading suppliers of digital printing. The state of the art printing technology we use in our production process gives our customers the best print quality. We are expertise in all kinds of gifts for corporate needs, Industries, Institutions, Banks, Hotels, Social clubs.

    banner standss
    best car wrap
    best yard signs
    blank yard signs
    business cards orlando
    car wrap design orlando
    car wraps orlando
    cheap printing orlando
    cheap t-shirts

    Visit here: http://www.orlandoprinters.com/

    ReplyDelete
  22. We’re a local roastery based in the heart of the Ottawa Valley. Since 1998, we’ve been roasting and delivering fresh coffee each and every week. We have a passion for good coffee and a deep respect for the people who grow it.

    Fair trade coffee in Canada
    Weekly delivery in Canada
    Direct trade coffee in Canada
    Single origin coffees Canada
    Espresso best Canada
    Espresso best Canada
    coffee roaster Canada
    coffee roastery in Canada
    coffee shop roaster in Canada
    local coffee roasters in Canada
    roastery coffee house in Canada
    natural coffee in Canada
    coffee house in Canada
    fresh roasted coffee in Canada


    Visit here: https://www.equator.ca/
    Elgin St.
    Ottawa, ON K1P 5W1
    equatornac.cna@gmail.com
    613.563.7771

    ReplyDelete